Cookbooks and Recipe Testing
I recently read a very interesting article by Neil Parmar in the August 2006 issue of Smart Money magazine. It's called "Cooked Books". Neil brings up a very good point that many newer cookbooks put out by celebrity chefs along with ghostwriters can be recipes for disaster as some or all of the recipes are hastily tested.
If you are an avid cookbook collector like I am, it is very disappointing to hear that these books are cranked out so quickly without proper "real life" testing. I have recently been asked to test recipes for a well known publication called "Cooks Illustrated". They are renowned for scientifically testing and taking apart recipes and cooking techniques to perfect each recipe. I have to say that every recipe I have tested so far has been either perfect or almost perfect. And that's the reason that they ask "home cooks" to test their recipes before publication.
It can be time consuming and expensive to depend upon recipe testers. But some cookbook authors like Mario Batali will use them as backup when unsure about how a recipe is working. Recipes prepared in commercial kitchens with every gadget known to the culinary world may not always work well in a home cooking environment. Many celebrity recipes were created for restaurants. Translation to the home cook can be daunting.
However there are many cookbooks today that are specifically created for the home chef. These recipes are typically tested and retested in varying home cooking environments before publication.
So, buyer beware. If you should be in the market for a new cookbook as apparently many people are today, just keep in mind that there may be some flaws in the recipes. As such, you shouldn't blame yourself if the recipe fails. Check and double check the recipe to see if you notice something unusual. Some publishers will post edits on their websites, some not. Keep track of what went wrong and edit as you go if necessary. Many times recipes can be used as a guide for ingredients and you can add and delete at will. The exception is in baking where exact measurements are critical to the finished product.
Trust the classic cookbooks and avid cooking websites. These recipes are typically tested for the home cook.
Happy Cooking!


